Milky Way Midnight (Forever Yours) - 1.76 oz bar
Milky Way Midnight (Forever Yours) - 1.76 oz bar - unwrapped
Milky Way Midnight (Forever Yours) - 1.76 oz bar - 6 bars
Milky Way Midnight (Forever Yours) - 1.76 oz bar - box of 24 open
Milky Way Midnight (Forever Yours) - 1.76 oz bar - box of 24
Milky Way Family Page

Milky Way Midnight (Forever Yours) - 1.76 oz bar

Regular price $2.19
Sale price $2.19 Regular price
Sale OUT OF STOCK

Forever Yours has a new name - Milky Way Midnight, a candy bar with rich dark chocolate, caramel and nougat. 

Email When Available
Free shipping on orders over $100.  Learn more
Add to wishlist

Customer Reviews

Based on 17 reviews
94%
(16)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
6%
(1)
C
Camilla S. (Milford, DE, US)
Love these Midnight Milky Way Bars!!!

Thank you OldTimeCandy for having these bars on your website! I bought a box of 24-count 1.76 size bars, and they arrived in perfect condition. I put a few in the refrigerator because I love cold chocolate, and these bars are SOOOOOOO YUMMY!!! I just went on your website again to order more, but they are out of stock, so I checked the box to email me as soon as the Midnight Milky Way bars are back in stock.

s
sky0kast

Always my weakness

S
Sara R. (Opelousas, LA, US)
Birthday gift

My bestie loves Milky Way Midnights!

s
sky0kast

Guilty (gear) addiction

A
Anonymous (Boardman, OR, US)

Guilty (gear) addiction

M
M.m.

Excellent

M
Marjorie (Boardman, OR, US)

Excellent

I
Isidorina

Mom’s Favorite

I
Isidorina (Boardman, OR, US)

Mom’s Favorite

S
Suzanne

I’m a dark chocolate fan

Candy memories

Everyone has their own special memories involving candy we grew up eating. We are very excited to hear yours!
Brian
Maryland

When my 2 sisters and I were young, back in the late 50’s, our Dad would take us to the neighborhood playground. When we were playing in the sandbox, Dad would toss coins into the sand when we weren’t looking. We really thought we were finding lost treasure!

Read more about Shop candy coins memories
Kris
Indiana

This was back when this candy was called $100,000 bars, not 100 Grand bars. I remember going to my friend Cori's birthday party in elementary school, maybe third grade. At the party her mom told us that we were each going to get $100,000...

Read more about shop 100 grand memories
Juanita
Kentucky

When I was a kid we always got Good and Plenty when we went to the movies. My sister would only eat the pink ones, even though I kept telling her they tasted the same as the white ones. Just seeing them today reminds me of my little sister and the sweet taste of black licorice.

Read more about Shop Good & Plenty memories