$9.95 Flat-Rate Shipping, FREE over $250. Phone Orders 1-866-929-5477 - 9AM to 4PM EST, MON - FRI

Skip to content

Candy For You Login | Register My Bag 0

Bag Summary

0 Items: $0.00

{item.quantity}

Free

Remove

View All {cart.item_count} Items

View Bag

Your bag is currently empty.

Find your favorite candy...

WALK THE CANDY AISLE
View All Candy
CANDY BY DECADE
- Pre 1920s
- 1920s
- 1930s
- 1940s
- 1950s
- 1960s
- 1970s
- 1980s
- 1990s
View All Decades
CANDY BY FLAVOR
- Almond
- Banana
- Butter Rum
- Butterscotch
- Caramel
- Cherry
- Chocolate
- Cinnamon
- Licorice
- Peanut Butter
View All Flavors
CANDY BY TYPE
View All Candy By Type
CANDY BY OCCASION
View All Candy by Occassion
CANDY GIFTS
View All Candy Gifts
CANDY ASSORTMENTS
BULK CANDY
PACK-A-BAG

Menu
Login / Register
My Bag

Home > Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter

Filter Results

Displaying:
Products

Filter By:

Displaying: Products

Sign up for discounts and more!

Email Address

Customer Service

FAQS
Shipping
$9.95 Flat-Rate Shipping
APO/FPO Shipping
Candy Coins (Rewards)
Terms & Conditions
Corporate Gifts
Phone Orders
Coupon Codes

Safe Shopping

100% Satisfaction
Security
Privacy Policy
Better Business Bureau

About Us

History & Mission
Water Wells for Africa
Candy Blog
Reward For Finding Site Errors

Quick Links

Bulk Candy
Candy By Brands
Candy by Color
Retro Toys
Party Favors
Gift Card
Candy On Sale
Discontinued Candy
Affiliate Programs
Candy Museum

Follow Us

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Instagram

1-866-929-5477
9am - 4pm EST
Mon - Fri

© 2019 The Old Time Candy Company, All Rights Reserved