Skip to content

$9.95 flat rate US ground shipping. Free for orders over $250.

Our Best Sellers Login | Register My Bag 0 items

Find your favorite candy...

WALK THE CANDY AISLE
View All Candy
CANDY BY DECADE
- Pre 1920s
- 1920s
- 1930s
- 1940s
- 1950s
- 1960s
- 1970s
- 1980s
- 1990s
View All Decades
CANDY BY FLAVOR
- Almond
- Banana
- Butter Rum
- Butterscotch
- Caramel
- Cherry
- Chocolate
- Cinnamon
- Licorice
- Peanut Butter
View All Flavors
CANDY BY TYPE
View All Candy By Type
CANDY BY OCCASION
View All Candy by Occasion
CANDY GIFTS
View All Candy Gifts
CANDY ASSORTMENTS
BULK CANDY
PACK-A-BAG
RETRO TOYS

Menu
Phone Orders
Login / Register
items My Bag

Home > Peanut Butter

Peanut Butter

Candy you ate as a kid® is available in many flavors including peanut butter flavored candy.

Filter Results

Filter By:

Sign up for discounts and more!

Customer Service

FAQS
Shipping
$9.95 Flat-Rate Shipping
APO/FPO Shipping
Candy Coins (Rewards)
Terms & Conditions
Corporate Gifts
Phone Orders
Coupon Codes

Safe Shopping

100% Satisfaction
Security
Privacy Policy
Better Business Bureau
Shipping Insurance

About Us

History & Mission
Water Wells for Africa
Candy Blog
Reward For Finding Site Errors

Quick Links

Bulk Candy
Candy By Brands
Candy by Color
Retro Toys
Party Favors
Gift Card
Candy On Sale
Discontinued Candy
Affiliate Programs
Candy Museum

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Instagram

1-866-929-5477
9am - 4pm EST
Mon - Fri

Return to Main Content

My Bag

Skip To Gift and Checkout Content

{property.name}: Upload Succesful {property.value}

FREE

−

+

×

Remove

Your bag is currently empty.

Continue browsing here.

Giving Back

Donate to help build water wells in Africa.

A small donation of just $1.00 or $2.00, the cost of a single bottle of water, will have an impact. To show our appreciation we will match your donation dollar for dollar.
Learn more about our giving back program

$2 $1 $3 $4 $5

hide gift options

Customize gift message and delayed delivery options.

Toggle Gift Options

Complementary Hand-Written Gift Card (Optional)

Complementary Hand-Written Gift Card

100 Characters Remaining

Delay Shipping (Optional)

A minimum of one week’s notice is required.

Desired Arrival Date

hide gift options

Rewards Earned

0 Candy Coins

Include shipping protection for only $0.98 extra. Learn More

Toggle Shipping Insurance

Subtotal ( items)

$0.00

Delayed Shipping Attribute