Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Wax Mustaches - box of 24
Reward Points What's This?
12 points will be rewarded to you when you buy this item.
Wax Mustaches - box of 24
SKU: 37560
In Stock
Wax Mustaches were gone for quite a while but now they are back. They only come in one color but have a wonderful grape flavor.

Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day.

Your Price:
Write a Review  Add to Wish List
Do you have a favorite "candy you ate as a kid" story? Share it here.

When I was a kid, I could hardly wait for the market next to my school to get the box of wax stuff for Halloween. I would buy a black mustache and an orange wax whistle. While walking home, about a 1/2 mile, I pretended to be disguised, but by the time I got home the mustache would be over half chewed as I loved the licorice flavor. When I walked thru the front door my mom would say "I see Otto's got in the wax stuff". I would smile and ask for a dime to buy more the next day. Still such a sweet memory today. ~From Rebecca in Illinois
Average Rating review  
Wax Mustaches
  Wonderful website. My order arrived far faster than I expected in great shape. We took the mustaches to our Thanksgiving dinner and snapped pictures of those who wanted to pose while wearing them. It was fun and we got some great pictures for our memory book. Thanks for the great service and the quality product.
  Reviewed by:  Candace from Las Vegas, NV. on 1/11/2014
Loads of fun!
  Bought these for kids attending our vintage base ball games. Loads of fun and well received by the children, and their parents! People enjoyed wearing their mustaches and looking like history. www.welkinbbc.com
  Reviewed by:  Jim Fisher from Port Huron MI. on 5/21/2013
Lots of Fun!
  I ordered these to be passed out at my daughter's wedding reception after dinner and during the dancing. The guests had a lot of fun with them and they made for some great pictures!
  Reviewed by:  Judith Braham from Venice, Florida. on 6/14/2011
  We put these in goody bags for a 70's theme birthday party- EVERYONE loved them!! I would have put a big bowl of them out at the beginning of the party if I had known how much fun they were! We have the funniest pictures of young and old with their wax lips and wax mustaches on! I highly recommend! They smell great and are fun to chew just as we remembered! They were boxed as pictured and all of them were in perfect shape!
  Reviewed by:  Jill Zachlod from Pleasanton, CA. on 5/27/2011
oh fun, oh cinco de mayo fun.........
  so, my daughter graduated with honors, from NMSU in Las Cruces, New Mexico, on Cinco de Mayo...we, her family and friends and fellow graduates, celebrated with sombreros, margaritas, pinatas, and MUSTACHES!!!!!.....her 90 year old grandmother looked especially festive with one on....... so, gracias! keep on keepin' on, an appreciative mother
  Reviewed by:  Nita Larronde from Pie jTown, New Mexico. on 5/24/2011

Recently Viewed Items
Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront