Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (20)
1920s Candy (15)
1930s Candy (13)
1940s Candy (8)
1950s Candy (3)
1960s Candy (2)
1970s Candy (7)
1990s Candy (2)
Brown (25)
Pink (2)
White (6)
Yellow (3)
Assorted (7)
Bulk Candy (18)
Glass Jars with Candy (1)
King Size - boxes (1)
King Size - singles (1)
Mini Size - boxes & bags (5)
Mini size - singles (2)
Peg Bags - cases (4)
Peg Bags - singles (4)
Plastic Tubs (6)
Regular Size - boxes (12)
Regular Size - singles (12)
Single Wrapped Pieces (2)
Theater Box - cases (3)
Theater Box - singles (3)
Annabelle Candy (8)
Atkinson Candy (19)
Boyer's Candy (2)
Hershey's (16)
Necco (16)
Nestle' (3)
Pennsylvania Dutch Candies (2)
Reese's (9)
RetroFuture Products (2)
Peanut Butter
Total Items: 70
[1] 2 - Next » All
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar
$0.29
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar - 15 lb bulk case
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar - 15 lb bulk case
$89.99
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar - 2 lb bulk bag
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar - 2 lb bulk bag
$15.99
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar - 5 lb bulk bag
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar - 5 lb bulk bag
$31.99
Abba Zaba - 2 oz bar
Abba Zaba - 2 oz bar
$1.19
Abba Zaba - 2 oz bar - box of 24
Abba Zaba - 2 oz bar - box of 24
$23.99
Abba Zaba Peanut Butter & Jelly - 1.8 oz bar
Abba Zaba Peanut Butter & Jelly - 1.8 oz bar
$1.19
Abba Zaba Peanut Butter & Jelly - 1.8 oz bar - box of 24
Abba Zaba Peanut Butter & Jelly - 1.8 oz bar - box of 24
$23.99
Butterfingers - 2.1 oz bar
Butterfingers - 2.1 oz bar
$1.19
Butterfingers - 2.1 oz bar - box of 36 bars
Butterfingers - 2.1 oz bar - box of 36 bars
$35.99
Butterfingers Mini Bars - 2 lb Plastic Tub
Butterfingers Mini Bars - 2 lb Plastic Tub
$17.99
Chick-o-Sticks - 1 oz - 1 piece
Chick-o-Sticks - 1 oz - 1 piece
$0.49
Chick-o-Sticks - 1 oz - box of 24
Chick-o-Sticks - 1 oz - box of 24
$7.99
Chick-o-Sticks - king size 2 oz
Chick-o-Sticks - king size 2 oz
$1.19
Chick-o-Sticks - king size 2 oz - box of 24
Chick-o-Sticks - king size 2 oz - box of 24
$23.99
Chick-o-Sticks Nuggets - 2 lb bulk bags
Chick-o-Sticks Nuggets - 2 lb bulk bags
$9.99
Chick-O-Sticks Nuggets - 3 lb Plastic Tub
Chick-O-Sticks Nuggets - 3 lb Plastic Tub
$16.99
Chick-o-Sticks Nuggets - 30 lb bulk case
Chick-o-Sticks Nuggets - 30 lb bulk case
$103.99
Chick-o-Sticks Nuggets - 5 lb bulk bags
Chick-o-Sticks Nuggets - 5 lb bulk bags
$19.99
Chick-o-Sticks sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
Chick-o-Sticks sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
$2.49
Chick-o-Sticks sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag - case of 12
Chick-o-Sticks sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag - case of 12
$23.99
Clark Bar - 2.1 oz bar
Clark Bar - 2.1 oz bar
$1.19
Clark Bar - 2.1 oz bar - box of 24
Clark Bar - 2.1 oz bar - box of 24
$23.99
Clark Bar Jr - 0.5 oz - 1 piece
Clark Bar Jr - 0.5 oz - 1 piece
$0.35
Clark Bar Jr - 0.5 oz - 100 piece tub
Clark Bar Jr - 0.5 oz - 100 piece tub
$26.99
Clark Bar Mini - 3.5 oz theater box
Clark Bar Mini - 3.5 oz theater box
$1.79
Clark Bar Mini - 3.5 oz theater box - case of 12
Clark Bar Mini - 3.5 oz theater box - case of 12
$16.99
Clark Bites - 2.3 oz pack
Clark Bites - 2.3 oz pack
$1.19
Clark Bites - 2.3 oz pack - box of 24
Clark Bites - 2.3 oz pack - box of 24
$23.99
Glass Candy Jar (Mary Janes)
Glass Candy Jar (Mary Janes)
$23.99
Honeycombed Peanuts - 2 lb bulk bag
Honeycombed Peanuts - 2 lb bulk bag
$9.99
Honeycombed Peanuts - 30 lb bulk case
Honeycombed Peanuts - 30 lb bulk case
$104.99
Honeycombed Peanuts - 5 lb bulk bag
Honeycombed Peanuts - 5 lb bulk bag
$19.99
Mary Janes - 2 lb bulk bag
Mary Janes - 2 lb bulk bag
$9.99
Mary Janes - 3.5 oz theater box
Mary Janes - 3.5 oz theater box
$1.79
Mary Janes - 3.5 oz theater box - case of 12
Mary Janes - 3.5 oz theater box - case of 12
$16.99
Mary Janes - 30 lb bulk case
Mary Janes - 30 lb bulk case
$99.99
Mary Janes - 4 lb plastic tub
Mary Janes - 4 lb plastic tub
$19.99
Mary Janes - 4.5 oz bag
Mary Janes - 4.5 oz bag
$1.99
Mary Janes - 4.5 oz bag - box of 12
Mary Janes - 4.5 oz bag - box of 12
$21.89
Mary Janes - 5 lb bulk bag
Mary Janes - 5 lb bulk bag
$19.99
Nutrageous - 1.66 oz bar - box of 18
Nutrageous - 1.66 oz bar - box of 18
$17.99
Nutrageous - 1.8 oz bar
Nutrageous - 1.8 oz bar
$1.19
Peanut Butter Bars - 2 lb bulk bags
Peanut Butter Bars - 2 lb bulk bags
$10.99
 
[1] 2 - Next » All


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront