Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (120)
1920s Candy (69)
1930s Candy (56)
1940s Candy (48)
1950s Candy (78)
1960s Candy (70)
1970s Candy (98)
1980s Candy (49)
1990s Candy (22)
Almond (2)
Anise (1)
Apple (19)
Banana (14)
Blackberry (2)
Blue Raspberry (10)
Blueberry (2)
Butter Rum (2)
Butterscotch (3)
Caramel (23)
Cherry (35)
Chocolate (82)
Cinnamon (12)
Clove (2)
Coconut (4)
Coffee (1)
Cotton Candy (6)
Grape (13)
Honey (5)
Horehound (2)
Lemon (11)
Licorice (17)
Maple (2)
Marshmallow (3)
Nougat (7)
Orange (5)
Peanut (14)
Peanut Butter (23)
Pecan (3)
Peppermint (22)
Pineapple (1)
Popcorn (1)
Raspberry (1)
Rock Candy (3)
Root Beer (5)
Spearmint (5)
Strawberry (29)
Sugar (4)
Tootsie (4)
Tropical Flavors (9)
Vanilla (7)
Violet (2)
Watermelon (12)
Wintergreen (1)
Bubble & Chewing Gum (68)
Candy Cigarettes & Cigars (7)
Candy Drops (12)
Candy Sticks (27)
Caramel (23)
Chewy Candy (130)
Chocolate - dark (19)
Chocolate - milk (91)
Chocolate - white (2)
Coconut (7)
Cotton Candy (2)
Cough Drops (8)
Gluten Free (1)
Gummi Candy (7)
Hard Candy (60)
Hot Candy (11)
Jawbreakers (8)
Jelly Candy (11)
Jewelry Candy (7)
JuJu Candy (5)
Licorice (29)
Lollipops & Suckers (39)
Made in USA (262)
Marshmallow Candy (13)
Mellocreme Candy (1)
Mints (6)
Money Candy (3)
Nostalgia Gums (3)
Nougat Candy (13)
Novelty Candy (81)
Nut Candy (23)
Panned Candy (18)
Peanut Butter Candy (20)
Pez (8)
Powdered Candy (5)
Retro Snacks (15)
Rock Candy (3)
Sour Candy (36)
Sugar-free (12)
Sweetart Style Candy (18)
Taffy (44)
Tootsie (7)
Wax Candy (7)
Pack-a-Bag

You choose what goes into the candy bag.  Each Pack-a-Bag can hold roughly 5 lbs of candy.  If needed, we will use more than one bag.  Click one of the filters on the left to select decade, flavor or type of candy.

If sent as a gift, Free, hand-written gift cards (by actual real people) are available during checkout and we will tie the gift bag with a colorful ribbon. Let the fun begin!
Total Items: 624
[1] 2 3 4 5 6 7 ...[11] - Next » All
100 Grand Bar - 1.5 oz bar
100 Grand Bar - 1.5 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
3 Musketeers - 2.13 oz bar
3 Musketeers - 2.13 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
5th Avenue bar - 2 oz bar
5th Avenue bar - 2 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar
Abba Zaba - 0.43 oz mini bar
$0.29 Quantity
Abba Zaba - 2 oz bar
Abba Zaba - 2 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Abba Zaba Peanut Butter & Jelly - 1.8 oz bar
Abba Zaba Peanut Butter & Jelly - 1.8 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Airheads - Blue Raspberry - 0.55 oz bar
Airheads - Blue Raspberry - 0.55 oz bar
$0.29 Quantity
Airheads - Cherry - 0.55 oz bar
Airheads - Cherry - 0.55 oz bar
$0.29 Quantity
Airheads - Green Apple - 0.55 oz bar
Airheads - Green Apple - 0.55 oz bar
$0.29 Quantity
Airheads - Pink Lemonade - 0.55 oz bar
Airheads - Pink Lemonade - 0.55 oz bar
$0.29 Quantity
Airheads - Watermelon - 0.55 oz bar
Airheads - Watermelon - 0.55 oz bar
$0.29 Quantity
Airheads - White Mystery - 0.55 oz bar
Airheads - White Mystery - 0.55 oz bar
$0.29 Quantity
Almond Joy - 1.61 oz bar
Almond Joy - 1.61 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Andes Mints - 4.67 oz pkg
Andes Mints - 4.67 oz pkg
$2.69 Quantity
Andy Capp's Cheddar Fries - 3 oz bag
Andy Capp's Cheddar Fries - 3 oz bag
$1.59 Quantity
Andy Capp's Hot Fries - 3 oz bag
Andy Capp's Hot Fries - 3 oz bag
$1.59 Quantity
Andy Capp's Hot Fries - 8 oz "big" bag
Andy Capp's Hot Fries - 8 oz "big" bag
$3.29 Quantity
Appleheads - 0.8 oz box
Appleheads - 0.8 oz box
$0.39 Quantity
Astronaut Ice Cream - 1 pack
Astronaut Ice Cream - 1 pack
$2.99 Quantity
Atomic Fireballs - 4.75 oz bag
Atomic Fireballs - 4.75 oz bag
$1.99 Quantity
Baby Bottle Pops 1.1 oz - 1 piece
Baby Bottle Pops 1.1 oz - 1 piece
$1.99 Quantity
Baby Ruth - 2.1 oz bar
Baby Ruth - 2.1 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Banana Splits - 6 oz bag
Banana Splits - 6 oz bag
$2.39 Quantity
Bananarama / Banana Runts - 5 oz bag
Bananarama / Banana Runts - 5 oz bag
$1.99 Quantity
Barnum's Animal Crackers - 2.125 oz box
Barnum's Animal Crackers - 2.125 oz box
$2.49 Quantity
BB Bats - 5 oz bag
BB Bats - 5 oz bag
$2.49 Quantity
BB Bats - Banana - 1 piece
BB Bats - Banana - 1 piece
$0.25 Quantity
BB Bats - Chocolate - 1 piece
BB Bats - Chocolate - 1 piece
$0.25 Quantity
BB Bats - Strawberry - 1 piece
BB Bats - Strawberry - 1 piece
$0.25 Quantity
BB Bats - Vanilla - 1 piece
BB Bats - Vanilla - 1 piece
$0.25 Quantity
Beemans gum - 1 pack
Beemans gum - 1 pack
$1.29 Quantity
Beer Nuts - 1.25 oz peanuts
Beer Nuts - 1.25 oz peanuts
$1.19 Quantity
Big Cherry - 1.75 oz bar
Big Cherry - 1.75 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Big Hunk - 0.43 oz mini bar
Big Hunk - 0.43 oz mini bar
$0.29 Quantity
Big Hunk - 2 oz bar
Big Hunk - 2 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Big League Chew - grape - 2.1 oz pouch
Big League Chew - grape - 2.1 oz pouch
$1.69 Quantity
Big League Chew - original - 2.1 oz pouch
Big League Chew - original - 2.1 oz pouch
$1.69 Quantity
Big League Chew - sour apple - 2.1 oz pouch
Big League Chew - sour apple - 2.1 oz pouch
$1.69 Quantity
Big League Chew - watermelon - 2.1 oz pouch
Big League Chew - watermelon - 2.1 oz pouch
$1.69 Quantity
Big Red Gum - 1 pack
Big Red Gum - 1 pack
$0.45 Quantity
Bit-O-Honey - 1.7 oz bar
Bit-O-Honey - 1.7 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Bit-O-Honey - 4 oz bag
Bit-O-Honey - 4 oz bag
$1.99 Quantity
Black Cow - 1.5 oz bar
Black Cow - 1.5 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Black Cow bite-size - 1 piece
Black Cow bite-size - 1 piece
$0.25 Quantity
Black Jack Gum - 1 pack
Black Jack Gum - 1 pack
$1.29 Quantity
Blow Pops - assorted flavors - 1 pop
Blow Pops - assorted flavors - 1 pop
$0.25 Quantity
Blow Pops - black ice - 1 pop
Blow Pops - black ice - 1 pop
$0.25 Quantity
Blow Pops - blue raspberry - 1 pop
Blow Pops - blue raspberry - 1 pop
$0.25 Quantity
Blow Pops - bursting berry - 1 pop
Blow Pops - bursting berry - 1 pop
$0.25 Quantity
Blow Pops - cherry - 1 pop
Blow Pops - cherry - 1 pop
$0.25 Quantity
Blow Pops - cherry ice - 1 pop
Blow Pops - cherry ice - 1 pop
$0.25 Quantity
Blow Pops - kiwi berry blast - 1 pop
Blow Pops - kiwi berry blast - 1 pop
$0.25 Quantity
Blow Pops - sour apple - 1 pop
Blow Pops - sour apple - 1 pop
$0.25 Quantity
Blow Pops - Super - assorted flavors - 1 pop
Blow Pops - Super - assorted flavors - 1 pop
$0.39 Quantity
Blow Pops - tangerine mango madness - 1 pop
Blow Pops - tangerine mango madness - 1 pop
$0.25 Quantity
Bonomo's Taffy Nibbles Banana - 1.5 oz pkg
Bonomo's Taffy Nibbles Banana - 1.5 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Bonomo's Taffy Nibbles Vanilla - 1.5 oz pkg
Bonomo's Taffy Nibbles Vanilla - 1.5 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy - 1.5 oz banana bar
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy - 1.5 oz banana bar
$1.19 Quantity
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy - 1.5 oz chocolate bar
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy - 1.5 oz chocolate bar
$1.19 Quantity
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy - 1.5 oz strawberry bar
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy - 1.5 oz strawberry bar
$1.19 Quantity
 
[1] 2 3 4 5 6 7 ...[11] - Next » All


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront