Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Home > Discontinued Candy and Gum

Discontinued Candy and Gum

Discontinued Candy

Please note:
Discontinued means that it is gone, we do not have any and we don't know where to find it. Also, please don't blame us. Either the manufacturer made the decision or went out of business. We are disappointed too.

Click a picture to see a larger version. All candy boxes are from Donny's personal collection.

This page has a long load time, please be patient.

  • 10:30 candy bar
  • Abba-Zaba chocolate (Choco-Zaba - discontinued in 1998)
  • Adams Sour gums
  • Alpine White candy bar
  • Bar None by Hershey
  • Big Mouth Bubble Gum
  • Big Pay candy barBig Pay candy bar
  • Big TimBig Tim candy box
  • Big TimeBig Time Candy Bar
  • Bit-O-Licorice
  • Beech-Nut Spearmint and Wintergreen Gum
  • Beeman gum available from time to time.
  • Ben Hurs, try Anise Squares
  • Big Buddy Bubble Gum
  • Big Mouth Suckers
  • Black Cat Bubble Gum
  • Black Cow sucker, try Black Cow Bars
  • Black Jack gum available from time to time.
  • Black Licorice Dollars Black Licorice Dollars candy
  • Blizzard Bar by BunteBlizzard Bar

  • Bob Cat Candy BarBob Cat candy
  • Brock's (not Brach's) candy puffs (very soft, melt in your mouth candy balls)Brock's Candy Balls
  • Bonkers Fruit Chews
  • Bub's Daddy bubble gum ropes
  • Butternut candy barButternut candy
  • Candy Lipsticks that were wrapped in gold paper and cellophane. They were bright red, rubbed off on your lips and dissolved in your mouth as you ate it. Try Cherry Flipsticks which are similar.
  • Candy Lipsticks (Sweetart style with plastic case)Candy Lipsticks
  • Candy Raisins
  • CaravelleCaravelle candy bar
  • Cherry-a-LetCherry-a-Let candy bar
  • Cherry Humps Cherry Humps candy bar
  • Chicken Bones, try Chic-O-SticksChicken Bones
  • Chicken Dinner candy barChicken Dinner candy
  • Choco'Lite candy bar
  • Chug-a-Can of CandyChug a Can of Candy
  • Chum Gum
  • Clark Coconut Bar Clark Coconut Bar
  • Clove gum available from time to time.
  • Danish Ribbons - try Broadway Rolls
  • Dazzle Candy Bar Dazzle Candy
  • Delfa Rolls - try Broadway Rolls
  • Denver Sandwich Bar Denver Sandwich Candy
  • Dr. Pepper Gum
  • Dragon Fire Hot Cinnamon Gum
  • Dynamints
  • Dino-Sour Eggs (Wonka... egg shaped jawbreakers)
  • Fannie Farmer candies (now owned by Fanny Mae Candies) Fannie Farmer's candyFannie Farmer Candies
  • Fan Tan gum
  • Fizzers
  • Forever Yours - try Milky Way MidnightForever Yours Candy
  • Forrest Gump box of chocolate Forrest Gump box of chocolate
  • Fortune Bubble Gum
  • Gatorade Gum
  • Goodnuff Peanut Bars Goodnuff Peanut Bars
  • Hershey-ets Hershey-etes candy
  • High Noon candy bar
  • Hot Dog Bubble Gum
  • Hollywood candy bar
  • Ice Cream gum
  • Jingles
  • Life Savers - Clove, Tangerine, All Sour Flavors, Cinnamon: current Life Savers flavors
  • Licorice Whips Licorice Whips
  • Love Nest candy bars Love Nest candy bars
  • Lunch Bar Lunch candy bar
  • Luv Pops Luv Pops
  • Marathon Bar, see Curly Wurly
  • Mary Janes, chocolate covered
  • Mars Bar, see Snickers Almond
  • Mars Coconut BarMars Coconut Candy
  • Merri Mints
  • Milkshake candy bar Milkshake candy bar
  • My Buddy Candy Bar
  • Mr. Melons / Melonheads
  • Neapolitan Coconut Sundaes by Brach's
  • Now and Later... thriller, bubble gum, mystery mix, rum caramel, rainbow and raspberry flavors. There are still other flavors available: current Now and Laters flavors
  • Old Nick candy bar Old Nick candy bar
  • Oompahs, the new ones by Willy Wonka are not the same.
  • Orangeheads Orangeheads
  • Orange-Its, Grape-Its and Cherry-Its.
  • Pal Bubble Gum Pal Bubble Gum
  • PBMax candy bar
  • Pepsin gum
  • Pom Poms
  • Powerhouse candy bar Power House candy bar
  • Prairie Scooner Bar
  • Red Hot Dollars, try Juju CoinsRed Hot Dollars
  • Reed's Candy Rolls Reed's Candy Rolls
  • Regal Crown Sours
  • Reggie Bar
  • Schrafft's Chocolates Schrafft's Chocolates
  • Schrafft's Peppermint Patties Schrafft's Peppermint Patties
  • Screaming Yellow Zonkers
  • Sen Sen
  • seven Up candy bar, see Sky Bar (has 4 sections instead of 7) seven Up candy bar
  • Smooth Sailin candy bar Smooth Sailin candy bar
  • Snirkles Caramel Candy Snirkles Caramel Candy
  • Sno King candy bar Sno King candy bar
  • "Spoon Candy"... we are not sure if this is the actual name, but it was a tiny fluted pie dish with soft creamy fruit flavored or chocolate candy and a very small spoon. One person has reported that it was called Bottle Caps... not the current candy by the same name. Another person says, "This was actually a type of pudding. It was a stove-top made pudding and put in the refrigerator to cool with a chocolate topping that hardened as it cooled."
  • Sour Bites
  • Sprint chocolate bar
  • Sputnik Gumballs
  • Squirrel Nut Chocolate Caramels
  • Sugarloaf Soft Bubblegum
  • Sugar Mama
  • Summit Bar
  • Swell Bubble Gum Swell Bubble Gum
  • Sweety-Py candy bar Sweety-Py candy bar
  • Tangy Taffy
  • Tart-n-Tiny
  • Wacky Wafers
  • Waleco Candy Bar Waleco candy bar
  • Walnut Crush Walnut Crush candy bar
  • Wax Harmonicas, Whistles and Fingernails
  • Wazoo Candy Bar
  • Welch's Frappe Bar
  • Welch's Fudge Bar
  • Whistle Pops Whistle Pops
  • Whiz Bar Whiz Candy Bar
  • Wonderball
  • Wonka Bar Wonka Candy Bar
  • Yoo-Hoo chocolate bar
  • Y&S Licorice Sticks Y&S Licorice Sticks
Please note: Discontinued means that it is gone, we do not have any and we don't know where to find it. Also, please don't blame us. Either the manufacturer made the decision or went out of business. We are disappointed too.
Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront