Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Cinnamon Toothpicks - 0.1 oz tube - box  of 20
Reward Points What's This?
8 points will be rewarded to you when you buy this item.
Cinnamon Toothpicks - 0.1 oz tube - box of 20
SKU: 31590
In Stock
Cinnamon Toothpicks, do you remember these? Each plastic tube holds about 15 toothpicks which have been soaked in cinnamon for a long lasting flavor.

Orders placed by midnight usually ship on the next business day.

Your Price:
Write a Review  Add to Wish List
Do you have a favorite "candy you ate as a kid" story? Share it here.

These days, sour candy is the thing, but back when I was a kid, cinnamon was our favorite form of taste-bud masochism. I had never seen cinnamon toothpicks for sale on a store shelf, but the other children would bring bunches of toothpicks that they had soaked in cinnamon oil (the longer, the better) and preserved in aluminum foil.These dealers would sell just a few toothpicks to each of us for a considerable amount, making an enormous profit. (This dealer's price is MUCH, MUCH more reasonable.) The cinnamon toothpick was a rite of passage. The longer you could keep one in your mouth the cooler you were. Often we would chew the toothpick into splinters, trying to extract all of the tasty cinnamon oil.

If you were really brave, you would try cinnamon toilet-paper. The highly-absorbent toilet-paper was perfectly-suited to soaking up cinnamon oil. Just a spit-wad-sized bit tucked behind your lip felt like it was burning a hole through the inside of your mouth and bring tears to your eyes.Like many such pursuits (pencil-fighting and miniature motorized 4x4 truck pulls, for example), the school leadership would ban cinnamon toothpicks for no other apparent reason than that they supposedly disrupted the learning environment. Drugs in school were unheard of, at the time. ~ Clifton in Florida
Average Rating review  View All Reviews
Cinnamon Toothpicks
  Cinnamon Toothpicks had will nice and the tube they come in can be used for others things too. Will be order more of these when I run low.
  Reviewed by:  Connie Strobel from Fl.. on 1/28/2014
  I had been looking for these for a long time. I couldn't remember thr name brand of the ones my dad used to get us as kids. So glad for google lol. Looked up original cinnamon toothpicks and this site was in the first few results. I decided since I had tried different ones, why not? I ordered a box and they arrived in a few days. Tried one and couldn't believe it. Gave one to my dad tonight. He popped it in his mouth then yanked it out. He grinned and said "whew I forgot" lol. Totally worth it. 10 out of 10 would buy again. Thank yall for all the memories while browsing your site.
  Reviewed by:  dennis watson from Mississippi. on 8/2/2013
Nothing Compares!
  I've ordered cinnamon tooth pics from other companies and found myself disappointed by the lack of taste. Thankfull I stumbled upon this great product!! Amazing taste and fast delivery! What more could you ask for?
  Reviewed by:  Crystal from Colorado. on 3/22/2012
Instead of Smoking
  My daughter joined the Navy and wanted to stop smoking. Her Commander gave her a toothpick which started her on them instead of smoking. I remembered these as a kid and thought they might like the cinnamon and mint one instead of just regular toothpicks. Everyone loved them, and you never know who will quit smoking because of them. Good Luck to All.
  Reviewed by:  Susan Duncan from Long Beach, California. on 10/1/2011
Cinnamon Toothpicks
  Ordered them to assist me in quitting smoking. Plain tooth picks do not work but the cinnamon toothpicks are spicy and falvorful enough to chew on and keep your hands and mouth occupied. They are hot but they are supposed to be. Price is correct but shipping seems a little high. I give them 5 stars
  Reviewed by:  David Hutchison from Hopki ns SC. on 8/23/2011
Recently Viewed Items
Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront