Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (15)
1920s Candy (8)
1940s Candy (2)
1950s Candy (10)
1960s Candy (26)
1970s Candy (6)
1980s Candy (5)
Banana (40)
Butterscotch (4)
Lemon (17)
Peanut Butter (3)
Pineapple (2)
Bulk Candy (27)
Mini Size - boxes & bags (1)
Mini size - singles (1)
Peg Bags - cases (3)
Peg Bags - singles (3)
Plastic Tubs (5)
Regular Size - boxes (12)
Regular Size - singles (13)
Single Wrapped Pieces (4)
Small Packaging - boxes (1)
Small Packaging - singles (1)
Theater Box - cases (1)
Theater Box - singles (1)
Amerilab Technologies (2)
Atkinson Candy (3)
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy (5)
Brach's Confections (4)
C. Howard Company (2)
Candy you ate as a kid® peg bags (4)
Claey's Candy (2)
Concord Confections (5)
Ferrara Candy Company (17)
Gilliam Candy Company (6)
Just Born (1)
Necco (6)
Richardson Candy (3)
Wonka (6)
Yellow
Total Items: 72
« Previous - 1 [2]
Laffy Taffy 1.5 oz Banana Bar
Laffy Taffy 1.5 oz Banana Bar
$1.19
Laffy Taffy 1.5 oz Banana Bar - box of 24
Laffy Taffy 1.5 oz Banana Bar - box of 24
$23.99
Laffy Taffy Banana Rope
Laffy Taffy Banana Rope
$0.39
Laffy Taffy Banana Rope - box of 24
Laffy Taffy Banana Rope - box of 24
$7.99
Lemonheads - 0.8 oz box
Lemonheads - 0.8 oz box
$0.39
Lemonheads - 0.8 oz box - box of 24
Lemonheads - 0.8 oz box - box of 24
$6.99
Lemonheads - 1 piece
Lemonheads - 1 piece
$0.10
Lemonheads - 2 lb bulk bag
Lemonheads - 2 lb bulk bag
$9.99
Lemonheads - 27 lb bulk case
Lemonheads - 27 lb bulk case
$84.99
Lemonheads - 3 lb Plastic Tub
Lemonheads - 3 lb Plastic Tub
$15.99
Lemonheads - 5 lb bulk bag
Lemonheads - 5 lb bulk bag
$19.99
Lemonheads - 6 oz theater box
Lemonheads - 6 oz theater box
$1.79
Lemonheads - 6 oz theater box - case of 12
Lemonheads - 6 oz theater box - case of 12
$16.99
Now & Later - banana - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - banana - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49
Now & Later - banana - 0.93 oz pkg - box of 24
Now & Later - banana - 0.93 oz pkg - box of 24
$6.99
Now & Later - pineapple - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - pineapple - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49
Now & Later - pineapple - 0.93 oz pkg - box of 24
Now & Later - pineapple - 0.93 oz pkg - box of 24
$6.99
Now & Later Giant Soft Banana - 1 piece
Now & Later Giant Soft Banana - 1 piece
$0.15
Now & Later Giant Soft Banana - 38.1 oz tub
Now & Later Giant Soft Banana - 38.1 oz tub
$11.99
Now & Later Soft Banana - 0.93 oz pkg - box of 24
Now & Later Soft Banana - 0.93 oz pkg - box of 24
$6.99
Now & Later Soft Banana - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
Now & Later Soft Banana - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
$0.49
Peeps Yellow Marshmallow - box of 10
Peeps Yellow Marshmallow - box of 10
$1.99
Stick Candy - banana - 1 stick
Stick Candy - banana - 1 stick
$0.25
Stick Candy - banana - box of 80
Stick Candy - banana - box of 80
$13.99
Stick Candy - bubble gum - 1 stick
Stick Candy - bubble gum - 1 stick
$0.25
Stick Candy - bubble gum - box of 80
Stick Candy - bubble gum - box of 80
$13.99
Stick Candy - lemon - 1 stick
Stick Candy - lemon - 1 stick
$0.25
Stick Candy - lemon - box of 80
Stick Candy - lemon - box of 80
$13.99
 
« Previous - 1 [2]


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront