Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (18)
1920s Candy (6)
1930s Candy (3)
1940s Candy (6)
1950s Candy (9)
1960s Candy (4)
1970s Candy (1)
1980s Candy (3)
Anise (1)
Apple (1)
Banana (2)
Caramel (2)
Cherry (2)
Chocolate (4)
Cinnamon (3)
Coffee (1)
Honey (1)
Horehound (1)
Lemon (1)
Licorice (4)
Peanut Butter (4)
Peppermint (2)
Root Beer (2)
Strawberry (3)
Watermelon (1)
Wintergreen (1)
Black (3)
Brown (10)
Green (1)
Orange (1)
Pastel (1)
Pink (1)
Red (9)
White (2)
Yellow (3)
Assorted (10)
Adams & Brooks (1)
Albanese Candy (2)
Albert's Candy (1)
American Licorice (2)
Andre Prost Inc. (1)
Atkinson Candy (2)
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy (1)
Candy you ate as a kid® peg bags (9)
Claey's Candy (12)
Concord Confections (3)
Ferrara Candy Company (1)
Gerrit Verburg Candy (1)
Goetze's Candy (1)
Haribo of America (2)
Hershey's (4)
Necco (7)
Nestle' (1)
Pennsylvania Dutch Candies (15)
Sunrise (1)
Wonka (1)
Peg Bags - singles
Total Items: 51
[1] 2 - Next » All
Atomic Fireballs - 4.75 oz bag
Atomic Fireballs - 4.75 oz bag
$1.99
Banana Splits - 6 oz bag
Banana Splits - 6 oz bag
$2.39
Bananarama / Banana Runts - 5 oz bag
Bananarama / Banana Runts - 5 oz bag
$1.99
BB Bats - 5 oz bag
BB Bats - 5 oz bag
$2.49
Bit-O-Honey - 4 oz bag
Bit-O-Honey - 4 oz bag
$1.99
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy - 2.5 oz bag
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy - 2.5 oz bag
$1.99
Canada Mints 7 oz bag - Peppermint (white)
Canada Mints 7 oz bag - Peppermint (white)
$2.19
Canada Mints 7 oz bag - Wintergreen (pink)
Canada Mints 7 oz bag - Wintergreen (pink)
$2.19
Candy Buttons - bag of 4 strips
Candy Buttons - bag of 4 strips
$1.99
Candy Drops - anise - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - anise - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - assorted fruit flavors - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - assorted fruit flavors - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - cherry - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - cherry - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - cinnamon - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - cinnamon - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - green apple - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - green apple - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - horehound - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - horehound - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - lemon - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - lemon - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - licorice - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - licorice - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - peppermint - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - peppermint - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - root beer - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - root beer - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - sassafras - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - sassafras - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Candy Drops - watermelon - 6 oz bag
Candy Drops - watermelon - 6 oz bag
$1.99
Caramel Creams - 3.5 oz bag
Caramel Creams - 3.5 oz bag
$1.99
Cherry Sours - 8 oz bag
Cherry Sours - 8 oz bag
$1.99
Chick-o-Sticks sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
Chick-o-Sticks sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
$2.49
Choco Rocks - 4 oz bag
Choco Rocks - 4 oz bag
$2.49
Chocolate Babies - 5 oz bag
Chocolate Babies - 5 oz bag
$1.99
Coffee Rio - 5.5 oz bag
Coffee Rio - 5.5 oz bag
$3.49
Dubble Bubble Gum - sugar-free - 3.25 oz bag
Dubble Bubble Gum - sugar-free - 3.25 oz bag
$2.99
Gummi Bears - 5.25 oz bag
Gummi Bears - 5.25 oz bag
$1.99
Gummi Worms - 5.25 oz bag
Gummi Worms - 5.25 oz bag
$1.99
Haribo Gold Bears - 5 oz bag
Haribo Gold Bears - 5 oz bag
$1.89
Hershey's Milk Chocolate - sugar-free - 3 oz bag
Hershey's Milk Chocolate - sugar-free - 3 oz bag
$3.59
Ice Cube Chocolates - 4 oz bag
Ice Cube Chocolates - 4 oz bag
$3.99
Jolly Ranchers - Cinnamon Fire - 7 oz bag
Jolly Ranchers - Cinnamon Fire - 7 oz bag
$2.99
Jolly Ranchers - sugar-free assorted - 3.6 oz bag
Jolly Ranchers - sugar-free assorted - 3.6 oz bag
$3.49
Kits Taffy - 5 oz bag
Kits Taffy - 5 oz bag
$2.49
Licorice Laces - 4 oz bag
Licorice Laces - 4 oz bag
$1.99
Licorice Wheels - strawberry - 5 oz bag
Licorice Wheels - strawberry - 5 oz bag
$1.99
Mary Janes - 4.5 oz bag
Mary Janes - 4.5 oz bag
$1.99
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
$2.49
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag
$1.99
Red Vines Sugar-Free Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz bag
Red Vines Sugar-Free Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz bag
$2.99
Red Vines Sugar-Free Strawberry Twists - 5 oz bag
Red Vines Sugar-Free Strawberry Twists - 5 oz bag
$2.99
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - sugar-free 3 oz bag
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - sugar-free 3 oz bag
$3.59
 
[1] 2 - Next » All


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront