Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (20)
1920s Candy (17)
1930s Candy (12)
1940s Candy (8)
1950s Candy (3)
1960s Candy (2)
1970s Candy (7)
1990s Candy (2)
Brown (25)
Pink (2)
White (6)
Yellow (3)
Assorted (7)
Bulk Candy (18)
Glass Jars with Candy (1)
King Size - boxes (1)
King Size - singles (1)
Mini Size - boxes & bags (5)
Mini size - singles (2)
Peg Bags - cases (4)
Peg Bags - singles (4)
Plastic Tubs (6)
Regular Size - boxes (13)
Regular Size - singles (13)
Single Wrapped Pieces (2)
Theater Box - cases (3)
Theater Box - singles (3)
Annabelle Candy (8)
Atkinson Candy (19)
Boyer's Candy (2)
Hershey's (18)
Necco (16)
Nestle' (3)
Pennsylvania Dutch Candies (2)
Reese's (9)
RetroFuture Products (2)
Peanut Butter
Total Items: 71
« Previous - 1 [2]
Peanut Butter Bars - 3 lb Plastic Tub
Peanut Butter Bars - 3 lb Plastic Tub
$16.99
Peanut Butter Bars - 30 lb bulk case
Peanut Butter Bars - 30 lb bulk case
$109.99
Peanut Butter Bars - 5 lb bulk bags
Peanut Butter Bars - 5 lb bulk bags
$21.99
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
$2.49
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag - case of 12
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag - case of 12
$25.99
Reese's Big Cup - 1.4 oz pkg
Reese's Big Cup - 1.4 oz pkg
$1.19
Reese's Big Cup - 1.4 oz pkg - box of 16
Reese's Big Cup - 1.4 oz pkg - box of 16
$16.99
Reese's Mini Peanut Butter Cups - 4 lb Plastic Tub
Reese's Mini Peanut Butter Cups - 4 lb Plastic Tub
$29.99
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - 1.5 oz pkg
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - 1.5 oz pkg
$1.19
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - 1.5 oz pkg - box of 36
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - 1.5 oz pkg - box of 36
$35.99
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - miniatures - 1 piece
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - miniatures - 1 piece
$0.19
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - miniatures - box of 105
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - miniatures - box of 105
$12.99
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - sugar-free 3 oz bag
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - sugar-free 3 oz bag
$3.59
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - sugar-free 3 oz bag - case of 12
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - sugar-free 3 oz bag - case of 12
$36.99
Reese's Pieces - 1.53 oz pkg
Reese's Pieces - 1.53 oz pkg
$1.19
Reese's Pieces - 1.53 oz pkg - box of 36
Reese's Pieces - 1.53 oz pkg - box of 36
$35.99
Reese's Pieces - 2 lb bulk bag
Reese's Pieces - 2 lb bulk bag
$12.99
Reese's Pieces - 25 lb bulk case
Reese's Pieces - 25 lb bulk case
$114.99
Reese's Pieces - 4 oz theater box
Reese's Pieces - 4 oz theater box
$1.99
Reese's Pieces - 4 oz theater box - case of 12
Reese's Pieces - 4 oz theater box - case of 12
$18.99
Reese's Pieces - 5 lb bulk bag
Reese's Pieces - 5 lb bulk bag
$25.99
Smoothie - 1.6 oz pkg
Smoothie - 1.6 oz pkg
$1.19
Smoothie - 1.6 oz pkg - box of 24
Smoothie - 1.6 oz pkg - box of 24
$23.99
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar
$2.29
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar - box of 12
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar - box of 12
$24.99
Zagnut - 1.75 oz bar
Zagnut - 1.75 oz bar
$1.19
Zagnut - 1.75 oz bar - box of 18
Zagnut - 1.75 oz bar - box of 18
$17.99
 
 
« Previous - 1 [2]


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront