Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (122)
1920s Candy (69)
1930s Candy (56)
1940s Candy (46)
1950s Candy (82)
1960s Candy (72)
1970s Candy (98)
1980s Candy (50)
1990s Candy (22)
Almond (2)
Anise (1)
Apple (19)
Banana (14)
Blackberry (2)
Blue Raspberry (10)
Blueberry (2)
Butter Rum (2)
Butterscotch (3)
Caramel (23)
Cherry (35)
Chocolate (87)
Cinnamon (12)
Clove (2)
Coconut (4)
Coffee (1)
Cotton Candy (6)
Grape (13)
Honey (5)
Horehound (2)
Lemon (11)
Licorice (17)
Maple (2)
Marshmallow (3)
Nougat (7)
Orange (5)
Peanut (14)
Peanut Butter (25)
Pecan (3)
Peppermint (23)
Pineapple (1)
Popcorn (1)
Raspberry (1)
Rock Candy (3)
Root Beer (5)
Spearmint (5)
Strawberry (29)
Sugar (4)
Tootsie (4)
Tropical Flavors (9)
Vanilla (7)
Violet (2)
Watermelon (12)
Wintergreen (1)
Bubble & Chewing Gum (70)
Candy Cigarettes & Cigars (7)
Candy Drops (12)
Candy Sticks (27)
Caramel (23)
Chewy Candy (134)
Chocolate - dark (20)
Chocolate - milk (94)
Chocolate - white (2)
Coconut (7)
Cotton Candy (2)
Cough Drops (8)
Gummi Candy (8)
Hard Candy (61)
Hot Candy (12)
Jawbreakers (8)
Jelly Candy (11)
Jewelry Candy (6)
JuJu Candy (5)
Licorice (29)
Lollipops & Suckers (39)
Made in USA (264)
Marshmallow Candy (13)
Mellocreme Candy (1)
Mints (7)
Money Candy (3)
Nostalgia Gums (3)
Nougat Candy (13)
Novelty Candy (84)
Nut Candy (23)
Panned Candy (18)
Peanut Butter Candy (21)
Pez (9)
Powdered Candy (5)
Retro Snacks (15)
Rock Candy (3)
Sour Candy (36)
Sugar-free (12)
Sweetart Style Candy (19)
Taffy (44)
Tootsie (7)
Wax Candy (7)
Pack-a-Bag
Total Items: 639
« Previous - [1]... 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 - Next » All
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - sugar-free 3 oz bag
Reese's Peanut Butter Cups - sugar-free 3 oz bag
$3.59 Quantity
Reese's Peanut Butter Egg 1.2 oz
Reese's Peanut Butter Egg 1.2 oz
$1.19 Quantity
Reese's Peanut Butter Eggs 1.2 oz - box of 36
Reese's Peanut Butter Eggs 1.2 oz - box of 36
$35.99 Quantity
Reese's Pieces - 1.53 oz pkg
Reese's Pieces - 1.53 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Reese's Pieces - 4 oz theater box
Reese's Pieces - 4 oz theater box
$1.99 Quantity
Ring Pop Gummies - 1.7 oz pack
Ring Pop Gummies - 1.7 oz pack
$1.19 Quantity
Ring Pops - assorted flavors - 1 piece
Ring Pops - assorted flavors - 1 piece
$0.79 Quantity
Ring Pops Twisted - 1 pop
Ring Pops Twisted - 1 pop
$0.85 Quantity
Rock Candy Crystals - 2.5 oz box
Rock Candy Crystals - 2.5 oz box
$1.19 Quantity
Rock Candy Swizzle Sticks - assorted flavors - wrapped - 1 piece
Rock Candy Swizzle Sticks - assorted flavors - wrapped - 1 piece
$0.79 Quantity
Rock Candy Swizzle Sticks - white - wrapped - 1 piece
Rock Candy Swizzle Sticks - white - wrapped - 1 piece
$0.69 Quantity
Rocky Road - 0.33 oz mini bar - 1 piece
Rocky Road - 0.33 oz mini bar - 1 piece
$0.39 Quantity
Rocky Road - 1.82 oz bar
Rocky Road - 1.82 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Rolo - 1.7 oz roll
Rolo - 1.7 oz roll
$1.19 Quantity
Root Beer Barrels - 4.75 oz bag
Root Beer Barrels - 4.75 oz bag
$1.99 Quantity
Runts - 5 oz theater box
Runts - 5 oz theater box
$1.79 Quantity
Runts Chewy - 1.85 oz pkg
Runts Chewy - 1.85 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Saf-T-Pops - assorted flavors - 1 piece
Saf-T-Pops - assorted flavors - 1 piece
$0.19 Quantity
Salt Water Taffy - 4.25 oz bag
Salt Water Taffy - 4.25 oz bag
$1.99 Quantity
Satellite Wafers - 0.85 oz bag
Satellite Wafers - 0.85 oz bag
$1.99 Quantity
Scooter Pie - 2.0 oz Twin Pack
Scooter Pie - 2.0 oz Twin Pack
$1.19 Quantity
Scripture Mints - 1 piece
Scripture Mints - 1 piece
$0.10 Quantity
Sixlets - 1.75 oz pack
Sixlets - 1.75 oz pack
$1.19 Quantity
Sixlets - tube of 20 - 1 tube
Sixlets - tube of 20 - 1 tube
$0.29 Quantity
Skittles Original - 2.17 oz pkg
Skittles Original - 2.17 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Skittles Original 4 oz theater box
Skittles Original 4 oz theater box
$1.99 Quantity
Skittles Sour - 1.8 oz pkg
Skittles Sour - 1.8 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Skittles Sour 3.6 oz theater box
Skittles Sour 3.6 oz theater box
$1.99 Quantity
Skittles Tropical - 2.17 oz pkg
Skittles Tropical - 2.17 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Skor - 1.4 oz bar
Skor - 1.4 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Sky Bar - 1.5 oz bar
Sky Bar - 1.5 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Slap Stix Caramel Pop - 0.7 oz
Slap Stix Caramel Pop - 0.7 oz
$0.59 Quantity
Slim Jims - 0.28 oz - 4 inches
Slim Jims - 0.28 oz - 4 inches
$0.39 Quantity
Slo Poke - 1.5 oz bar
Slo Poke - 1.5 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Smarties - Giant Size - 1 oz roll
Smarties - Giant Size - 1 oz roll
$0.45 Quantity
Smarties - Mega Size - 2.25 oz roll
Smarties - Mega Size - 2.25 oz roll
$1.19 Quantity
Smarties 3.5 oz theater box
Smarties 3.5 oz theater box
$1.79 Quantity
Smarties Gummies - 1.34 oz roll
Smarties Gummies - 1.34 oz roll
$1.09 Quantity
Smith Brothers Cough Drops - licorice - 1 box
Smith Brothers Cough Drops - licorice - 1 box
$1.09 Quantity
Smith Brothers Cough Drops - wild cherry - 1 box
Smith Brothers Cough Drops - wild cherry - 1 box
$1.09 Quantity
Smoothie - 1.6 oz pkg
Smoothie - 1.6 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Snickers - 1.86 oz bar
Snickers - 1.86 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Snickers Almond (Mars Bar) - 1.76 oz bar
Snickers Almond (Mars Bar) - 1.76 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Snickers Fun Size Bars - 1 piece
Snickers Fun Size Bars - 1 piece
$0.39 Quantity
Sno Caps - 3.1 oz theater box
Sno Caps - 3.1 oz theater box
$1.79 Quantity
Sour Patch Kids - 2 oz pkg
Sour Patch Kids - 2 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Sour Patch Kids - wrapped - 1 piece
Sour Patch Kids - wrapped - 1 piece
$0.10 Quantity
Sour Patch Kids Extreme - 3.5 oz theater box
Sour Patch Kids Extreme - 3.5 oz theater box
$1.49 Quantity
Sour Punch Twists - assorted flavors - 1 pc
Sour Punch Twists - assorted flavors - 1 pc
$0.19 Quantity
Space Food Sticks - chocolate - 1.27 oz bar
Space Food Sticks - chocolate - 1.27 oz bar
$2.29 Quantity
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar
$2.29 Quantity
Spearmint Gum - 1 pack
Spearmint Gum - 1 pack
$0.45 Quantity
SpongeBob Plastic Easter Egg and Stickers
SpongeBob Plastic Easter Egg and Stickers
$1.49 Quantity
Spree - 1.77 oz roll
Spree - 1.77 oz roll
$1.19 Quantity
Spree - 5 oz theater box
Spree - 5 oz theater box
$1.89 Quantity
Spree Chewy - 1.7 oz pkg
Spree Chewy - 1.7 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Squirrel Nut Zippers - 4.25 oz bag
Squirrel Nut Zippers - 4.25 oz bag
$1.99 Quantity
Starburst FaveReds 2.07 oz roll
Starburst FaveReds 2.07 oz roll
$1.19 Quantity
Starburst Fun-Size - 1 pack
Starburst Fun-Size - 1 pack
$0.19 Quantity
Starburst Original - 2.07 oz roll
Starburst Original - 2.07 oz roll
$1.19 Quantity
 
« Previous - [1]... 6 7 8 [9] 10 11 - Next » All


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront