Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (122)
1920s Candy (69)
1930s Candy (56)
1940s Candy (46)
1950s Candy (82)
1960s Candy (72)
1970s Candy (98)
1980s Candy (50)
1990s Candy (22)
Almond (2)
Anise (1)
Apple (19)
Banana (14)
Blackberry (2)
Blue Raspberry (10)
Blueberry (2)
Butter Rum (2)
Butterscotch (3)
Caramel (23)
Cherry (35)
Chocolate (87)
Cinnamon (12)
Clove (2)
Coconut (4)
Coffee (1)
Cotton Candy (6)
Grape (13)
Honey (5)
Horehound (2)
Lemon (11)
Licorice (17)
Maple (2)
Marshmallow (3)
Nougat (7)
Orange (5)
Peanut (14)
Peanut Butter (25)
Pecan (3)
Peppermint (23)
Pineapple (1)
Popcorn (1)
Raspberry (1)
Rock Candy (3)
Root Beer (5)
Spearmint (5)
Strawberry (29)
Sugar (4)
Tootsie (4)
Tropical Flavors (9)
Vanilla (7)
Violet (2)
Watermelon (12)
Wintergreen (1)
Bubble & Chewing Gum (70)
Candy Cigarettes & Cigars (7)
Candy Drops (12)
Candy Sticks (27)
Caramel (23)
Chewy Candy (134)
Chocolate - dark (20)
Chocolate - milk (94)
Chocolate - white (2)
Coconut (7)
Cotton Candy (2)
Cough Drops (8)
Gummi Candy (8)
Hard Candy (61)
Hot Candy (12)
Jawbreakers (8)
Jelly Candy (11)
Jewelry Candy (6)
JuJu Candy (5)
Licorice (29)
Lollipops & Suckers (39)
Made in USA (264)
Marshmallow Candy (13)
Mellocreme Candy (1)
Mints (7)
Money Candy (3)
Nostalgia Gums (3)
Nougat Candy (13)
Novelty Candy (84)
Nut Candy (23)
Panned Candy (18)
Peanut Butter Candy (21)
Pez (9)
Powdered Candy (5)
Retro Snacks (15)
Rock Candy (3)
Sour Candy (36)
Sugar-free (12)
Sweetart Style Candy (19)
Taffy (44)
Tootsie (7)
Wax Candy (7)
Pack-a-Bag
Total Items: 639
« Previous - [1]... 5 6 [7] 8 9 ...[11] - Next » All
M&M's Pretzel - 1.14 oz pkg
M&M's Pretzel - 1.14 oz pkg
Your Price: $1.19
On Sale: $0.89
Quantity
Mallo Cups - 1.6 oz 2-pack
Mallo Cups - 1.6 oz 2-pack
$1.19 Quantity
Mallo Cups 0.5 oz mini-size - 1 piece
Mallo Cups 0.5 oz mini-size - 1 piece
$0.49 Quantity
Mallo Cups Dark - 1.6 oz 2-pack
Mallo Cups Dark - 1.6 oz 2-pack
$1.19 Quantity
Mamba Fruit Chews - 2.65 oz roll - 1 roll
Mamba Fruit Chews - 2.65 oz roll - 1 roll
$1.19 Quantity
Marshmallow Ice Cream Cones - 2-pack
Marshmallow Ice Cream Cones - 2-pack
$0.75 Quantity
Mary Janes - 4.5 oz bag
Mary Janes - 4.5 oz bag
$1.99 Quantity
Mike & Ike - Jolly Joes - 1.8 oz pkg
Mike & Ike - Jolly Joes - 1.8 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Mike & Ike - original flavors - 1.8 oz pkg
Mike & Ike - original flavors - 1.8 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Mike & Ike - original flavors - 5 oz theater box
Mike & Ike - original flavors - 5 oz theater box
$1.89 Quantity
Mike & Ike Red Rageous - 2.12 oz pkg
Mike & Ike Red Rageous - 2.12 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Milk Duds - 1.85 oz box
Milk Duds - 1.85 oz box
$1.19 Quantity
Milk Duds - 5 oz theater box
Milk Duds - 5 oz theater box
$1.99 Quantity
Milky Way - 1.84 oz bar
Milky Way - 1.84 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Milky Way Midnight (Forever Yours) - 1.76 oz bar
Milky Way Midnight (Forever Yours) - 1.76 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Mint Juleps - 8 oz container
Mint Juleps - 8 oz container
$2.99 Quantity
Mint Lumps by Bobs - 1 piece
Mint Lumps by Bobs - 1 piece
$0.15 Quantity
Mint Straws - 9 oz bag
Mint Straws - 9 oz bag
Your Price: $1.99
On Sale: $0.99
Quantity
Mint Toothpicks - 0.1 oz tube
Mint Toothpicks - 0.1 oz tube
$0.99 Quantity
Moon Pie - Banana Double Decker - 1 piece
Moon Pie - Banana Double Decker - 1 piece
$0.99 Quantity
Moon Pie - Chocolate Double Decker - 1 piece
Moon Pie - Chocolate Double Decker - 1 piece
$0.99 Quantity
Moon Pie - Mini Chocolate - 1 piece
Moon Pie - Mini Chocolate - 1 piece
$0.55 Quantity
Mounds - 1.75 oz bar
Mounds - 1.75 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Mr Goodbar - 1.75 oz bar
Mr Goodbar - 1.75 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Necco Wafers - 0.5 oz mini roll
Necco Wafers - 0.5 oz mini roll
$0.35 Quantity
Necco Wafers - all chocolate - 2.02 oz roll
Necco Wafers - all chocolate - 2.02 oz roll
$1.19 Quantity
Necco Wafers - assorted - 2.02 oz roll
Necco Wafers - assorted - 2.02 oz roll
$1.19 Quantity
Necco Wafers - tropical - 2.02 oz roll
Necco Wafers - tropical - 2.02 oz roll
$1.19 Quantity
Nerds - grape and strawberry - 1.65 oz box
Nerds - grape and strawberry - 1.65 oz box
$0.99 Quantity
Nerds - lemon and sour apple - 1.65 oz box
Nerds - lemon and sour apple - 1.65 oz box
$0.99 Quantity
Nerds - wild cherry and watermelon - 1.65 oz box
Nerds - wild cherry and watermelon - 1.65 oz box
$0.99 Quantity
Nerds Giant Chewy 1.8 oz pkg
Nerds Giant Chewy 1.8 oz pkg
$1.19 Quantity
Nerds Mini Boxes - 1 box
Nerds Mini Boxes - 1 box
$0.25 Quantity
Nerds Rainbow - 5 oz theater box
Nerds Rainbow - 5 oz theater box
$1.79 Quantity
Nestle Crunch - 1.55 oz bar
Nestle Crunch - 1.55 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Nestle Milk Chocolate Bar - 1.45 oz bar
Nestle Milk Chocolate Bar - 1.45 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Now & Later - apple - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - apple - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - banana - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - banana - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - banana - 1 piece
Now & Later - banana - 1 piece
$0.10 Quantity
Now & Later - blue raspberry - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - blue raspberry - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - cherry - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - cherry - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - cherry/apple splits -  0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - cherry/apple splits - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - grape - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - grape - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - pineapple - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - pineapple - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - strawberry - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - strawberry - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - tropical lemonade -  0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - tropical lemonade - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - tropical punch -  0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - tropical punch - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - watermelon - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - watermelon - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later - wildberry -  0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
Now & Later - wildberry - 0.93 oz pkg - 6-pack
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later Giant Soft Assorted - 1 random piece
Now & Later Giant Soft Assorted - 1 random piece
$0.15 Quantity
Now & Later Giant Soft Banana - 1 piece
Now & Later Giant Soft Banana - 1 piece
$0.15 Quantity
Now & Later Original 18-piece bar
Now & Later Original 18-piece bar
$1.19 Quantity
Now & Later Soft 2.75 oz bar (cherry/grape/apple)
Now & Later Soft 2.75 oz bar (cherry/grape/apple)
$1.19 Quantity
Now & Later Soft 2.75 oz bar (watermelon/banana/strawberry)
Now & Later Soft 2.75 oz bar (watermelon/banana/strawberry)
$1.19 Quantity
Now & Later Soft Apple - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
Now & Later Soft Apple - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later Soft Banana - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
Now & Later Soft Banana - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later Soft Cherry - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
Now & Later Soft Cherry - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later Soft Grape - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
Now & Later Soft Grape - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later Soft Strawberry - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
Now & Later Soft Strawberry - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
$0.49 Quantity
Now & Later Soft Watermelon - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
Now & Later Soft Watermelon - 0.93 oz pkg of 6 pieces
$0.49 Quantity
 
« Previous - [1]... 5 6 [7] 8 9 ...[11] - Next » All


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront