Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (121)
1920s Candy (69)
1930s Candy (56)
1940s Candy (45)
1950s Candy (81)
1960s Candy (72)
1970s Candy (98)
1980s Candy (50)
1990s Candy (22)
Almond (2)
Anise (1)
Apple (19)
Banana (14)
Blackberry (2)
Blue Raspberry (10)
Blueberry (2)
Butter Rum (2)
Butterscotch (3)
Caramel (23)
Cherry (35)
Chocolate (83)
Cinnamon (12)
Clove (2)
Coconut (4)
Coffee (1)
Cotton Candy (6)
Grape (13)
Honey (5)
Horehound (2)
Lemon (11)
Licorice (17)
Maple (2)
Marshmallow (3)
Nougat (7)
Orange (5)
Peanut (14)
Peanut Butter (23)
Pecan (3)
Peppermint (23)
Pineapple (1)
Popcorn (1)
Raspberry (1)
Rock Candy (3)
Root Beer (5)
Spearmint (5)
Strawberry (29)
Sugar (4)
Tootsie (4)
Tropical Flavors (9)
Vanilla (7)
Violet (2)
Watermelon (12)
Wintergreen (1)
Bubble & Chewing Gum (70)
Candy Cigarettes & Cigars (7)
Candy Drops (12)
Candy Sticks (27)
Caramel (23)
Chewy Candy (133)
Chocolate - dark (20)
Chocolate - milk (90)
Chocolate - white (2)
Coconut (7)
Cotton Candy (2)
Cough Drops (8)
Gummi Candy (8)
Hard Candy (61)
Hot Candy (12)
Jawbreakers (8)
Jelly Candy (11)
Jewelry Candy (6)
JuJu Candy (5)
Licorice (29)
Lollipops & Suckers (39)
Made in USA (262)
Marshmallow Candy (13)
Mellocreme Candy (1)
Mints (7)
Money Candy (3)
Nostalgia Gums (3)
Nougat Candy (13)
Novelty Candy (82)
Nut Candy (23)
Panned Candy (18)
Peanut Butter Candy (19)
Pez (8)
Powdered Candy (5)
Retro Snacks (15)
Rock Candy (3)
Sour Candy (36)
Sugar-free (12)
Sweetart Style Candy (19)
Taffy (44)
Tootsie (7)
Wax Candy (7)
Pack-a-Bag
Total Items: 631
« Previous - 2 3 [4] 5 6 ...[11] - Next » All
Cow Tales - vanilla - 1 oz piece
Cow Tales - vanilla - 1 oz piece
$0.45 Quantity
Cow Tales Mini Tales - 1 piece
Cow Tales Mini Tales - 1 piece
$0.19 Quantity
Crows - 7.5 oz theater box
Crows - 7.5 oz theater box
$1.89 Quantity
Cry Baby Extra Sour bubble gum - 5-ball tube
Cry Baby Extra Sour bubble gum - 5-ball tube
$0.35 Quantity
Cry Baby Extra Sour bubble gum - wrapped - 1 piece
Cry Baby Extra Sour bubble gum - wrapped - 1 piece
$0.10 Quantity
Cry Baby Sour Mini Drinks - 1 piece
Cry Baby Sour Mini Drinks - 1 piece
$0.25 Quantity
Cry Baby Tears - 1.98 oz box
Cry Baby Tears - 1.98 oz box
$1.19 Quantity
Cup-O-Gold - 1.25 oz cup
Cup-O-Gold - 1.25 oz cup
$1.19 Quantity
Curly Wurly (Marathon Bar) - 0.9 oz bar
Curly Wurly (Marathon Bar) - 0.9 oz bar
$1.29 Quantity
Dentyne Gum - 1 pack
Dentyne Gum - 1 pack
$1.59 Quantity
Doublemint Gum - 1 pack
Doublemint Gum - 1 pack
$0.45 Quantity
Dove Dark Chocolate 1.44 oz bar
Dove Dark Chocolate 1.44 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Dove Milk Chocolate 1.44 oz bar
Dove Milk Chocolate 1.44 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Dubble Bubble assorted flavors - 1 piece
Dubble Bubble assorted flavors - 1 piece
$0.10 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Bits & Pieces 2.3 oz box
Dubble Bubble Bits & Pieces 2.3 oz box
$1.19 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Fizzers - 1.7 oz tube
Dubble Bubble Fizzers - 1.7 oz tube
$1.19 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Gum - 3 oz Big Bar (1928 flavor)
Dubble Bubble Gum - 3 oz Big Bar (1928 flavor)
$1.59 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Gum - sugar-free - 3.25 oz bag
Dubble Bubble Gum - sugar-free - 3.25 oz bag
$2.99 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Gum - twist wrap (long) - 1 piece
Dubble Bubble Gum - twist wrap (long) - 1 piece
$0.10 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Gum - twist wrap (short) - 1 piece
Dubble Bubble Gum - twist wrap (short) - 1 piece
$0.10 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Gum (flat pack) 1928 flavor - 3.5 oz theater box
Dubble Bubble Gum (flat pack) 1928 flavor - 3.5 oz theater box
$1.99 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Gumballs Original Fruit Flavors 12-piece tube
Dubble Bubble Gumballs Original Fruit Flavors 12-piece tube
$0.29 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Large Gumballs Assorted 12-piece tube
Dubble Bubble Large Gumballs Assorted 12-piece tube
$1.19 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Painterz Gumballs 5-piece tube
Dubble Bubble Painterz Gumballs 5-piece tube
$0.35 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Small Gumballs Assorted 12-piece tube
Dubble Bubble Small Gumballs Assorted 12-piece tube
$0.35 Quantity
Dubble Bubble Wrapped Gum Balls - 1 pc
Dubble Bubble Wrapped Gum Balls - 1 pc
$0.15 Quantity
Dum Dum Pops - assorted flavors - 1 piece
Dum Dum Pops - assorted flavors - 1 piece
$0.10 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Blue Razz - 12 tablet pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Blue Razz - 12 tablet pack
$2.99 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Cherry - 12 tablet pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Cherry - 12 tablet pack
$2.99 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - cherry 2-pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - cherry 2-pack
$1.29 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Cherry Cola - 12 tablet pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Cherry Cola - 12 tablet pack
$2.99 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Fizzin' Apple Cider - 8 tablet pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Fizzin' Apple Cider - 8 tablet pack
$2.99 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Fizzin' Hot Cocoa - 8 tablet pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Fizzin' Hot Cocoa - 8 tablet pack
$2.99 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Grape - 12 tablet pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Grape - 12 tablet pack
$2.99 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - grape 2-pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - grape 2-pack
$1.29 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Lemonade - 12 tablet pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Lemonade - 12 tablet pack
$2.99 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - lemonade 2-pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - lemonade 2-pack
$1.29 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Orange - 12 tablet pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Orange - 12 tablet pack
$2.99 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Root Beer - 12 tablet pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - Root Beer - 12 tablet pack
$2.99 Quantity
Fizzies Drink Tablets - root beer 2-pack
Fizzies Drink Tablets - root beer 2-pack
$1.29 Quantity
Flicks Chocolate Wafers - 1.6 oz tube
Flicks Chocolate Wafers - 1.6 oz tube
$1.49 Quantity
Flicks Dark Nonpareils - 1.6 oz tube
Flicks Dark Nonpareils - 1.6 oz tube
$1.49 Quantity
Flicks Milk Nonpareils - 1.6 oz tube
Flicks Milk Nonpareils - 1.6 oz tube
$1.49 Quantity
French Burnt Peanuts - 8 oz container
French Burnt Peanuts - 8 oz container
$2.99 Quantity
Freshen-up Gum - bubblegum - 1 pack
Freshen-up Gum - bubblegum - 1 pack
$0.89 Quantity
Freshen-up Gum - cinnamon - 1 pack
Freshen-up Gum - cinnamon - 1 pack
$0.89 Quantity
Freshen-up Gum - peppermint - 1 pack
Freshen-up Gum - peppermint - 1 pack
$0.89 Quantity
Freshen-up Gum - spearmint - 1 pack
Freshen-up Gum - spearmint - 1 pack
$0.89 Quantity
Fruit Slices (Boston Fruit) - assorted flavors - 5 oz bag
Fruit Slices (Boston Fruit) - assorted flavors - 5 oz bag
$3.99 Quantity
Fruit Slices (Boston Fruit) - sugar-free assorted - 5 oz bag
Fruit Slices (Boston Fruit) - sugar-free assorted - 5 oz bag
$5.99 Quantity
Fruit Stripe Gum - 1 pack
Fruit Stripe Gum - 1 pack
$1.19 Quantity
Gobstopper Pouches - 1 piece
Gobstopper Pouches - 1 piece
$0.39 Quantity
Gobstoppers - 1.77 oz box
Gobstoppers - 1.77 oz box
$1.19 Quantity
Gobstoppers - 5 oz theater box
Gobstoppers - 5 oz theater box
$1.99 Quantity
Gobstoppers - Chewy - 1.77 oz box
Gobstoppers - Chewy - 1.77 oz box
$1.19 Quantity
Gold Rocks Bubble Gum - 2 oz bag
Gold Rocks Bubble Gum - 2 oz bag
$1.59 Quantity
Goldenberg's Mini Peanut Chews - original - 1 piece
Goldenberg's Mini Peanut Chews - original - 1 piece
$0.25 Quantity
Goldenberg's Peanut Chews - milk chocolatety - 2 oz bar
Goldenberg's Peanut Chews - milk chocolatety - 2 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Goldenberg's Peanut Chews - original dark - 2 oz bar
Goldenberg's Peanut Chews - original dark - 2 oz bar
$1.19 Quantity
Goldenberg's Peanut Chews Original Dark - 3.8 oz theater box
Goldenberg's Peanut Chews Original Dark - 3.8 oz theater box
$1.89 Quantity
 
« Previous - 2 3 [4] 5 6 ...[11] - Next » All


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront