Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (234)
1920s Candy (106)
1930s Candy (81)
1940s Candy (67)
1950s Candy (131)
1960s Candy (39)
1970s Candy (64)
1980s Candy (55)
1990s Candy (9)
Almond (2)
Anise (5)
Apple (17)
Banana (25)
Blackberry (2)
Blue Raspberry (14)
Caramel (62)
Cherry (40)
Chocolate (116)
Cinnamon (4)
Coconut (6)
Coffee (2)
Cotton Candy (7)
Grape (8)
Honey (8)
Horehound (2)
Lemon (12)
Licorice (33)
Maple (4)
Marshmallow (9)
Nougat (12)
Orange (6)
Peanut (14)
Peanut Butter (57)
Pecan (2)
Peppermint (22)
Popcorn (2)
Rock Candy (12)
Root Beer (15)
Spearmint (5)
Strawberry (39)
Sugar (5)
Tootsie (10)
Vanilla (23)
Violet (4)
Walnut (4)
Watermelon (10)
Wintergreen (5)
Black (12)
Blue (15)
Brown (121)
Gold (2)
Green (16)
Orange (14)
Pastel (21)
Pink (11)
Purple (10)
Red (74)
White (42)
Yellow (24)
Assorted (141)
Bulk Candy (216)
Glass Jars with Candy (5)
King Size - boxes (15)
King Size - singles (23)
Lay-down Bags (7)
Mini Size - boxes & bags (17)
Mini size - singles (13)
Peg Bags - cases (31)
Peg Bags - singles (32)
Plastic Tubs (31)
Regular Size - boxes (168)
Regular Size - singles (169)
Resealable Bags (1)
Single Wrapped Pieces (22)
Small Packaging - boxes (1)
Small Packaging - singles (2)
Speciality Boxes & Tins (11)
Theater Box - cases (14)
Theater Box - singles (14)
Made in USA
Total Items: 798
« Previous - [1]... 12 13 [14] 15 16 ...[19] - Next » All
Pay Day - 1.85 oz bar - box of 24
Pay Day - 1.85 oz bar - box of 24
$23.99
Peanut Butter Bars - 2 lb bulk bags
Peanut Butter Bars - 2 lb bulk bags
$10.99
Peanut Butter Bars - 3 lb Plastic Tub
Peanut Butter Bars - 3 lb Plastic Tub
$16.99
Peanut Butter Bars - 30 lb bulk case
Peanut Butter Bars - 30 lb bulk case
$109.99
Peanut Butter Bars - 5 lb bulk bags
Peanut Butter Bars - 5 lb bulk bags
$21.99
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag
$2.49
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag - case of 12
Peanut Butter Bars - sugar-free - 3.75 oz bag - case of 12
$25.99
Peanut Patties - 2.5 oz - 1 piece
Peanut Patties - 2.5 oz - 1 piece
$1.19
Peanut Patties - 2.5 oz - bag of 16
Peanut Patties - 2.5 oz - bag of 16
$17.99
Pecan Pie - 3 oz
Pecan Pie - 3 oz
$1.09
Pecan Pie - 3 oz - box of 9
Pecan Pie - 3 oz - box of 9
$7.99
Pez Refill - assorted fruit candy - 6-pack
Pez Refill - assorted fruit candy - 6-pack
$2.19
Pez Refill - assorted fruit candy - 6-pack - box of 12
Pez Refill - assorted fruit candy - 6-pack - box of 12
$20.99
Pine Brothers Cough Drops - 1.94 oz natural honey
Pine Brothers Cough Drops - 1.94 oz natural honey
$3.99
Pine Brothers Cough Drops - 1.94 oz natural honey - box of 8
Pine Brothers Cough Drops - 1.94 oz natural honey - box of 8
$29.99
Pine Brothers Cough Drops - 1.94 oz wild cherry
Pine Brothers Cough Drops - 1.94 oz wild cherry
$3.99
Pine Brothers Cough Drops - 1.94 oz wild cherry - box of 8
Pine Brothers Cough Drops - 1.94 oz wild cherry - box of 8
$29.99
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag
$1.99
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag - box of 12
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag - box of 12
$21.89
Pixy Stix - 12.45 lb bulk case
Pixy Stix - 12.45 lb bulk case
$59.99
Pixy Stix - 2 lb bulk bag
Pixy Stix - 2 lb bulk bag
$14.99
Pixy Stix - 2 lb Plastic Tub
Pixy Stix - 2 lb Plastic Tub
$17.99
Pixy Stix - 5 lb bulk bag
Pixy Stix - 5 lb bulk bag
$29.99
Red Bird Peppermint Puffs - 1 piece
Red Bird Peppermint Puffs - 1 piece
$0.10
Red Bird Peppermint Puffs - 2 lb bulk bag
Red Bird Peppermint Puffs - 2 lb bulk bag
$9.99
Red Bird Peppermint Puffs - 20 lb bulk case
Red Bird Peppermint Puffs - 20 lb bulk case
$69.99
Red Bird Peppermint Puffs - 5 lb bulk bag
Red Bird Peppermint Puffs - 5 lb bulk bag
$19.99
Red Bird Puffs Assorted Flavors - 1 piece
Red Bird Puffs Assorted Flavors - 1 piece
$0.10
Red Bird Puffs Assorted Flavors - 2 lb bulk bag
Red Bird Puffs Assorted Flavors - 2 lb bulk bag
$9.99
Red Bird Puffs Assorted Flavors - 20 lb bulk case
Red Bird Puffs Assorted Flavors - 20 lb bulk case
$69.99
Red Bird Puffs Assorted Flavors - 5 lb bulk bag
Red Bird Puffs Assorted Flavors - 5 lb bulk bag
$19.99
Red Bird Soft Peppermint Sticks - 2 lb bulk bag
Red Bird Soft Peppermint Sticks - 2 lb bulk bag
$8.99
Red Bird Soft Peppermint Sticks - 28 lb bulk case
Red Bird Soft Peppermint Sticks - 28 lb bulk case
$84.99
Red Bird Soft Peppermint Sticks - 5 lb bulk bag
Red Bird Soft Peppermint Sticks - 5 lb bulk bag
$17.99
Red Vines Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz tray
Red Vines Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz tray
$1.99
Red Vines Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz tray - box of 24
Red Vines Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz tray - box of 24
$39.99
Red Vines Original Red Twists - 4 lb jar
Red Vines Original Red Twists - 4 lb jar
$14.99
Red Vines Original Red Twists - 5 oz tray
Red Vines Original Red Twists - 5 oz tray
$1.99
Red Vines Original Red Twists - 5 oz tray - box of 24
Red Vines Original Red Twists - 5 oz tray - box of 24
$39.99
Red Vines Original Red Whips - 2.5 oz bar
Red Vines Original Red Whips - 2.5 oz bar
$1.19
Red Vines Original Red Whips - 2.5 oz bar - box of 24
Red Vines Original Red Whips - 2.5 oz bar - box of 24
$23.99
Red Vines Sugar-Free Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz bag
Red Vines Sugar-Free Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz bag
$2.99
Red Vines Sugar-Free Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz bag - box of 12
Red Vines Sugar-Free Black Licorice Twists - 5 oz bag - box of 12
$27.99
Red Vines Sugar-Free Strawberry Twists - 5 oz bag
Red Vines Sugar-Free Strawberry Twists - 5 oz bag
$2.99
 
« Previous - [1]... 12 13 [14] 15 16 ...[19] - Next » All


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront