Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Pre 1920 Candy (96)
1920s Candy (36)
1930s Candy (20)
1940s Candy (28)
1950s Candy (36)
1960s Candy (32)
1970s Candy (51)
1980s Candy (54)
1990s Candy (20)
Banana (3)
Blue Raspberry (1)
Chocolate (23)
Licorice (11)
Peanut (6)
Peanut Butter (7)
Rock Candy (1)
Tropical Flavors (8)
Bulk Candy (118)
Glass Jars with Candy (2)
King Size - boxes (8)
King Size - singles (8)
Lay-down Bags (6)
Mini Size - boxes & bags (6)
Mini size - singles (7)
Peg Bags - cases (10)
Peg Bags - singles (10)
Plastic Tubs (14)
Regular Size - boxes (70)
Regular Size - singles (76)
Resealable Bags (1)
Single Wrapped Pieces (5)
Small Packaging - boxes (1)
Small Packaging - singles (2)
Speciality Boxes & Tins (5)
Theater Box - cases (17)
Theater Box - singles (18)
Adams & Brooks (17)
Albanese Candy (11)
American Licorice (3)
Andre Prost Inc. (4)
Bonomo's Turkish Taffy (4)
Boston Fruit Slice Company (4)
Brach's Confections (6)
Cadbury Adams (21)
Candy you ate as a kid® peg bags (5)
Charms Candy (15)
Claey's Candy (2)
Concord Confections (24)
Dryden & Palmer (1)
Ferrara Candy Company (34)
Ford Gum (11)
Gilliam Candy Company (4)
Gustaf's (5)
Haribo of America (5)
Hershey's (14)
Impact Confections (6)
Jelly Belly (8)
Just Born (7)
Kenny's Candy (3)
M&M Mars, Inc. (12)
McCraw's Candy (2)
Necco (17)
Pennsylvania Dutch Candies (10)
Perfetti Van Melle (1)
Pop Rocks (2)
Primrose Candy (3)
Reese's (7)
Richardson Candy (3)
Sconza Candy (9)
Spangler Candy (10)
Storck Candy (2)
Sunrise (6)
Sweet's Candy (4)
Sweetworks (6)
Tootsie Roll Industries (11)
Topps Gum & Candy (8)
Wonka (31)
Wrigley (19)
Assorted
Total Items: 382
« Previous - [1]... 4 5 6 7 8 [9]
Unicorn Pops - 18 inch (2.5 oz) - box of 36
Unicorn Pops - 18 inch (2.5 oz) - box of 36
$72.99
Unicorn Pops - 6 inch (0.4 oz) - 1 pop
Unicorn Pops - 6 inch (0.4 oz) - 1 pop
$0.49
Unicorn Pops - 6 inch (0.4 oz) - tub of 36
Unicorn Pops - 6 inch (0.4 oz) - tub of 36
$11.99
Warheads - 1 oz bag
Warheads - 1 oz bag
$0.99
Warheads - 1 oz bag - box of 12
Warheads - 1 oz bag - box of 12
$11.99
Warheads - 1 piece
Warheads - 1 piece
$0.10
Warheads - 2.5 lb plastic tub
Warheads - 2.5 lb plastic tub
$17.99
Warheads Chewy Cubes 2.5 oz package
Warheads Chewy Cubes 2.5 oz package
$1.19
Warheads Chewy Cubes 2.5 oz package - box of 15
Warheads Chewy Cubes 2.5 oz package - box of 15
$14.99
Wax Bottles - 1 wrapped bottle
Wax Bottles - 1 wrapped bottle
$0.25
Wax Bottles - 3 oz bag
Wax Bottles - 3 oz bag
$1.99
Wax Bottles - 3 oz bag - box of 12
Wax Bottles - 3 oz bag - box of 12
$21.89
Wax Bottles - 5-pack
Wax Bottles - 5-pack
$1.19
Wax Bottles - 5-pack - box of 18
Wax Bottles - 5-pack - box of 18
$19.99
Wax Bottles - box of 120
Wax Bottles - box of 120
$21.99
Whirly Pops - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - 1 pop
Whirly Pops - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - 1 pop
$1.79
Whirly Pops - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - 24 piece display
Whirly Pops - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - 24 piece display
$37.99
Whirly Pops - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - box of 60
Whirly Pops - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - box of 60
$83.99
Whirly Pops - 4 inch (3 oz) - 1 pop
Whirly Pops - 4 inch (3 oz) - 1 pop
$2.49
Whirly Pops - 4 inch (3 oz) - box of 48
Whirly Pops - 4 inch (3 oz) - box of 48
$88.99
Whirly Pops - 5.25 inch (6 oz) - 1 pop
Whirly Pops - 5.25 inch (6 oz) - 1 pop
$3.49
Whirly Pops - 5.25 inch (6 oz) - box of 36
Whirly Pops - 5.25 inch (6 oz) - box of 36
$103.99
Whirly Pops - 6.5 inch (10 oz) - 1 pop
Whirly Pops - 6.5 inch (10 oz) - 1 pop
$6.99
Whirly Pops - 6.5 inch (10 oz) - box of 18
Whirly Pops - 6.5 inch (10 oz) - box of 18
$92.99
Whirly Pops Happy Birthday - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - 1 pop
Whirly Pops Happy Birthday - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - 1 pop
$1.99
Whirly Pops Happy Birthday - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - box of 60
Whirly Pops Happy Birthday - 3 inch (1.5 oz) - box of 60
$89.99
Zotz - 2.25 lb Plastic Tub
Zotz - 2.25 lb Plastic Tub
$17.99
Zotz - 7-flavor assorted strings - box of 49
Zotz - 7-flavor assorted strings - box of 49
$19.99
Zotz - blue raspberry-orange-grape - box of 48 strings
Zotz - blue raspberry-orange-grape - box of 48 strings
$17.99
Zotz - cherry-apple-watermelon - box of 48 strings
Zotz - cherry-apple-watermelon - box of 48 strings
$17.99
  
 
« Previous - [1]... 4 5 6 7 8 [9]


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront