Old Time Candy Company
Shopping Cart 0 item(s)
Total: $0 view cart checkout
Follow Us

Deal of the Day
Walk the Candy Aisle Candy by Types Candy by Decades Candy by Occasions Pack-a-Bag Decade Boxes Party Favors Retro Toys What's New
Apple (8)
Banana (14)
Blue Raspberry (6)
Caramel (2)
Cherry (17)
Chocolate (6)
Cinnamon (6)
Grape (8)
Lemon (11)
Peanut Butter (2)
Peppermint (9)
Pineapple (2)
Rock Candy (2)
Spearmint (2)
Strawberry (24)
Sugar (2)
Tropical Flavors (7)
Watermelon (6)
Blue (7)
Gold (2)
Green (15)
Orange (2)
Pastel (24)
Pink (5)
Purple (8)
Red (51)
White (2)
Yellow (26)
Assorted (32)
Bulk Candy (39)
King Size - boxes (1)
King Size - singles (1)
Peg Bags - cases (4)
Peg Bags - singles (4)
Plastic Tubs (14)
Regular Size - boxes (56)
Regular Size - singles (57)
Single Wrapped Pieces (6)
Small Packaging - boxes (2)
Small Packaging - singles (2)
Theater Box - cases (7)
Theater Box - singles (7)
1960s Candy
Total Items: 215
« Previous - 1 2 3 [4] 5 - Next » All
Peeps Yellow Marshmallow - box of 10
Peeps Yellow Marshmallow - box of 10
$1.99
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag
$1.99
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag - box of 12
Pixy Stix - 1 oz bag - box of 12
$21.89
Pixy Stix - 12.45 lb bulk case
Pixy Stix - 12.45 lb bulk case
$59.99
Pixy Stix - 2 lb bulk bag
Pixy Stix - 2 lb bulk bag
$14.99
Pixy Stix - 2 lb Plastic Tub
Pixy Stix - 2 lb Plastic Tub
$17.99
Pixy Stix - 5 lb bulk bag
Pixy Stix - 5 lb bulk bag
$29.99
Pixy Stix - giant size - 1 piece
Pixy Stix - giant size - 1 piece
$0.45
Pixy Stix - giant size - box of 36
Pixy Stix - giant size - box of 36
$11.99
Razzles Original - 1.4 oz pkg
Razzles Original - 1.4 oz pkg
$1.19
Razzles Original - 1.4 oz pkg - box of 24
Razzles Original - 1.4 oz pkg - box of 24
$23.99
Razzles Sour - 1.4 oz pkg
Razzles Sour - 1.4 oz pkg
$1.19
Razzles Sour - 1.4 oz pkg - box of 24
Razzles Sour - 1.4 oz pkg - box of 24
$23.99
Razzles Tropical - 1.4 oz pkg
Razzles Tropical - 1.4 oz pkg
$1.19
Razzles Tropical - 1.4 oz pkg - box of 24
Razzles Tropical - 1.4 oz pkg - box of 24
$23.99
Remember When Booklet - 1960
Remember When Booklet - 1960
$5.99
Remember When Booklet - 1961
Remember When Booklet - 1961
$5.99
Remember When Booklet - 1962
Remember When Booklet - 1962
$5.99
Remember When Booklet - 1963
Remember When Booklet - 1963
$5.99
Remember When Booklet - 1964
Remember When Booklet - 1964
$5.99
Remember When Booklet - 1965
Remember When Booklet - 1965
$5.99
Remember When Booklet - 1966
Remember When Booklet - 1966
$5.99
Remember When Booklet - 1967
Remember When Booklet - 1967
$5.99
Remember When Booklet - 1968
Remember When Booklet - 1968
$5.99
Remember When Booklet - 1969
Remember When Booklet - 1969
$5.99
Rock Candy Swizzle Sticks - white - wrapped - 1 piece
Rock Candy Swizzle Sticks - white - wrapped - 1 piece
$0.69
Rock Candy Swizzle Sticks - white - wrapped - box of 72
Rock Candy Swizzle Sticks - white - wrapped - box of 72
$40.99
Scooter Pie - 2.0 oz Twin Pack
Scooter Pie - 2.0 oz Twin Pack
$1.19
Scooter Pie - 2.0 oz Twin Pack - box of 12
Scooter Pie - 2.0 oz Twin Pack - box of 12
$11.99
Slap Stix Caramel Pop - 0.7 oz
Slap Stix Caramel Pop - 0.7 oz
$0.59
Slap Stix Caramel Pops - 0.7 oz - box of 36
Slap Stix Caramel Pops - 0.7 oz - box of 36
$17.99
Space Food Sticks - chocolate - 1.27 oz bar
Space Food Sticks - chocolate - 1.27 oz bar
$2.29
Space Food Sticks - chocolate - 1.27 oz bar - box of 12
Space Food Sticks - chocolate - 1.27 oz bar - box of 12
$24.99
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar
$2.29
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar - box of 12
Space Food Sticks - peanut butter - 1.27 oz bar - box of 12
$24.99
Starburst FaveReds 2.07 oz roll
Starburst FaveReds 2.07 oz roll
$1.19
Starburst FaveReds 2.07 oz roll - box of 24
Starburst FaveReds 2.07 oz roll - box of 24
$23.99
Starburst Original - 2.07 oz roll
Starburst Original - 2.07 oz roll
$1.19
Starburst Original - 2.07 oz roll - box of 36
Starburst Original - 2.07 oz roll - box of 36
$35.99
Starburst Original 4 oz theater box
Starburst Original 4 oz theater box
$1.99
Starburst Original 4 oz theater box - case of 12
Starburst Original 4 oz theater box - case of 12
$18.99
Starburst Tropical - 2.07 oz roll
Starburst Tropical - 2.07 oz roll
$1.19
Starburst Tropical - 2.07 oz roll - box of 36
Starburst Tropical - 2.07 oz roll - box of 36
$35.99
Swedish Fish - Assorted - 2 lb bulk bag
Swedish Fish - Assorted - 2 lb bulk bag
$9.99
 
« Previous - 1 2 3 [4] 5 - Next » All


Click to verify
Old Time Candy Company is a BBB Accredited Business. Click for the Business Review of Old Time Candy Company in LaGrange OH Old Time Candy Company is upfront